Money touches every area of your life, and how you handle it reveals the true condition of your heart before God. When it comes to tithing, you've probably heard conflicting messages that leave you confused about what God actually expects from you. Some pastors demand exactly 10% while others say tithing ended with Christ. You deserve to know what Scripture actually teaches.
The Bible presents a clear pattern about giving that extends far beyond simple mathematics. From the very first tithe given by Abraham to the generous giving principles taught by Jesus and Paul, God's Word offers profound wisdom about how your relationship with money reflects your relationship with Him.
The First Tithe: Abraham's Response to God's Blessing
Before Moses received the Law, before the temple existed, Abraham demonstrated something powerful about giving. After rescuing his nephew Lot from enemy kings, Abraham encountered Melchizedek, the mysterious priest-king of Salem. Genesis 14:20 records that Abraham "gave him a tithe of all."
This wasn't a command Abraham followed—it was a spontaneous act of worship. He recognized that his victory came from "God Most High, Creator of heaven and earth," and he responded by giving one-tenth of the spoils of war to God's representative. Abraham understood that everything he possessed ultimately belonged to God.
Notice what motivated Abraham's tithe: gratitude, recognition of God's sovereignty, and acknowledgment that his success came from divine intervention, not his own strength. This sets the foundation for understanding biblical giving—it flows from a heart that recognizes God as the source of every blessing.
Jacob's Vow: Tithing as Covenant Response
Jacob made a similar commitment at Bethel when God appeared to him in a dream. Fleeing from his brother Esau's anger, Jacob experienced God's presence and heard promises about his future. Genesis 28:22 records his response: "Of all that you give me I will give you a tenth."
Jacob's vow reveals something crucial about tithing—it was never about earning God's favor but about responding to grace already received. God had already promised to bless Jacob, protect him, and bring him back safely. The tithe was Jacob's way of acknowledging these unmerited promises and demonstrating his trust in God's provision.
Both Abraham and Jacob tithed approximately 430 years before the Mosaic Law was given. This shows that generous giving to God isn't merely a legal requirement—it's a natural response of faith when you truly understand who God is and what He has done for you.
Old Testament Tithing Under the Law
When God established the nation of Israel, He instituted a formal tithing system that served both spiritual and civil purposes. The Old Testament actually required three different tithes, totaling much more than 10%:
The Levitical Tithe: Numbers 18:21-24 commanded Israelites to give one-tenth of their crops and livestock to support the Levites, who had no inheritance of land and devoted themselves to temple service.
The Festival Tithe: Deuteronomy 14:22-27 required a second tithe to fund the annual religious festivals and provide for communal celebrations before the Lord.
The Poor Tithe: Every third year, Deuteronomy 14:28-29 mandated an additional tithe to provide for widows, orphans, foreigners, and other vulnerable people in the community.
These weren't suggestions—they were legal requirements for Old Testament Israel. The tithes supported the religious, social, and economic infrastructure of a theocratic nation where church and state were unified under God's direct rule.
The Malachi Challenge: Context and Meaning
Malachi 3:8-10 contains the most quoted passage about tithing: "Will a man rob God? Yet you rob me. But you ask, 'How are we robbing you?' In tithes and offerings. Bring the whole tithe into the storehouse, that there may be food in my house. Test me in this, and see if I will not throw open the floodgates of heaven and pour out so much blessing that there will not be room enough to store it."
Understanding the context changes everything. Malachi was addressing the priests and people of Israel who had broken their covenant obligations. They were supposed to bring agricultural produce—grain, wine, oil, and livestock—to the temple storehouse to support the Levites and temple operations. Instead, they were keeping the best for themselves and bringing diseased, worthless animals.
This wasn't about Christians giving money to modern churches. It was about covenant unfaithfulness in a specific historical situation. The "storehouse" was a literal building for storing crops, not a metaphor for church treasuries. The rebuke concerned agricultural tithes required under the Mosaic Law, not a prescription for New Testament believers.
Jesus and Tithing: What Did He Actually Teach?
Jesus mentioned tithing only once, and His words might surprise you. In Matthew 23:23, He criticized the Pharisees: "Woe to you, teachers of the law and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You give a tenth of your spices—mint, dill and cumin. But you have neglected the more important matters of the law—justice, mercy and faithfulness. You should have practiced the latter, without neglecting the former."
Jesus wasn't condemning their tithing—He was exposing their misplaced priorities. They meticulously calculated tithes on garden herbs while ignoring love, justice, and mercy. Under the Old Covenant law they still lived under, their tithing was correct. But their hearts were wrong.
Significantly, Jesus never commanded His disciples to tithe. Instead, He taught radical generosity that went far beyond mathematical calculations. He told the rich young ruler to sell everything and give to the poor (Matthew 19:21). He praised the widow who gave her last two coins (Luke 21:1-4). He taught His followers to give to anyone who asks (Matthew 5:42).
New Testament Giving: The Heart of Generosity
When the apostles established the New Testament church, they never commanded tithing. Instead, they taught principles of generous, sacrificial giving motivated by love rather than law.
Paul's Revolutionary Teaching: In 2 Corinthians 9:7, Paul wrote: "Each of you should give what you have decided in your heart to give, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver." This directly contradicts legalistic tithing requirements. Your giving should be voluntary, purposeful, and joyful—not forced or calculated out of obligation.
The Macedonian Example: 2 Corinthians 8:1-5 describes believers who gave beyond their ability even in extreme poverty. They didn't give 10%—they gave everything they could because they understood grace. They "first gave themselves to the Lord" and then gave financially as an overflow of that surrender.
Regular, Proportional Giving: 1 Corinthians 16:2 encourages believers to "set aside a sum of money in keeping with your income" every week. Notice this isn't 10%—it's proportional to what you earn, allowing both poor and rich believers to participate meaningfully in supporting God's work.
The Principle Behind the Practice
The New Testament reveals that God isn't primarily interested in your money—He wants your heart. Tithing can be a useful starting point for learning to trust God with your finances, but it was never meant to be a ceiling or a rigid formula.
Consider these biblical principles for giving:
Give Proportionally: Your giving should reflect your income and circumstances. A struggling single mother's $20 might represent greater sacrifice than a wealthy person's $2,000.
Give Regularly: Consistent giving develops spiritual discipline and demonstrates ongoing trust in God's provision.
Give Joyfully: Your attitude matters more than the amount. God values cheerful generosity over reluctant obligation.
Give Sacrificially: True biblical giving costs you something. It should require faith and trust in God's provision.
Give Strategically: Support ministries, missionaries, and causes that advance God's kingdom and care for people in need.
When Tithing Becomes Legalism
Many churches teach tithing in ways that create spiritual bondage rather than freedom. You're not cursed if you don't give exactly 10%. God doesn't promise financial prosperity in exchange for tithing. Your salvation doesn't depend on your giving percentage.
Beware of teaching that uses Malachi 3:9 to threaten believers with curses for not tithing. That passage addressed Old Testament Israel's covenant breaking, not New Testament Christians. Similarly, promises of guaranteed financial return on tithing treat God like a cosmic vending machine rather than sovereign Lord.
Your giving should flow from gratitude and love, not fear of punishment or desire for material rewards. If you're giving to avoid God's anger or to manipulate Him into blessing you financially, you've missed the heart of biblical generosity entirely.
Practical Steps for Biblical Giving
Start Where You Are: If you're not currently giving, begin with whatever amount you can manage regularly. God honors faithful stewardship of little resources.
Grow Gradually: Increase your giving as your faith and income grow. Let God expand your heart for generosity over time.
Give Beyond Your Church: Support missionaries, feed the hungry, care for orphans, and help believers in need. Biblical giving extends far beyond institutional support.
Examine Your Motives: Are you giving out of love, gratitude, and trust in God? Or are you motivated by obligation, fear, or desire for return? Ask the Holy Spirit to purify your motives.
Plan Your Giving: Decide in advance what you'll give rather than responding emotionally to appeals. This allows for thoughtful stewardship and prevents manipulation.
The Heart God Desires
God doesn't need your money—He owns everything. What He desires is a heart that trusts Him completely with every area of life, including finances. Your giving reveals whether you truly believe God will provide for your needs or whether you're still trusting primarily in your own resources.
When you give generously and sacrificially, you're making a powerful declaration: "God is my source, my security, and my treasure. I trust Him to care for me more than I trust my bank account."
This kind of giving transforms your relationship with money and deepens your dependence on God. It breaks the power of materialism and demonstrates that your true citizenship is in heaven, not earth.
The Bible teaches that generous giving brings blessing—not necessarily financial prosperity, but the deeper joy of participating in God's work and experiencing His faithful provision. When you give with a pure heart, you store up treasures in heaven where moth and rust cannot destroy.
Your money will reveal what you truly worship. Make sure your giving reflects a heart fully surrendered to the One who gave His life for you.
Comments
Post a Comment